"All in the Family" and "Modern Family" are both situational comedies that deal with conflicts involving family relationships and societal issues in its time. In both shows, a dominant, patriarchal character is present in the form of Archie for "All in the Family" and Jay for "Modern Family." Jay and Archie are middle-aged family men who hold traditional American values. Their introduction and resistance to liberal values such as homosexuality provide comic relief. "Modern Family" also imitates a "mockumentary," interviewing family members during the show to provide insight to their thoughts.
Whereas "All in the Family" revolves mainly around Archie and his family, "Modern Family" revolves around three families to reflect different generational problems in America today. "Modern Family" reflects diversity in both culture, age, and sexuality, casting a vietnamese baby with homosexual parents, a Columbian wife and son, and teens of different ages. On the other hand, "All in the Family" maintains an all-white, heterosexual cast to reflect the everyday family during its time.
The issues that arise in one family are different from the issues that arise between three. "All in the Family" mainly deals with issues that arise due to Archie's prejudice or obstinate values. Since Archie's daughter is married, it does not place much emphasis on how to be a positive role model to one's children. On the contrary, "Modern Family" includes four teenagers, so it deals with all sorts of issues such as growing up and parenthood. It is also more culturally diverse, so the show often focuses on the clash between Latin American and Caucasian culture.
Both shows effectively communicate their message in ways that the audience in their time can relate to.
No comments:
Post a Comment